- Before a dismissal there must be a hearing: you must know what the allegations against you are, and get a real opportunity to respond to them.
- This applies to every employee, regardless of seniority, including during a trial period.
- The law has no formula for the compensation. The labor court awards a lump sum, based on all the circumstances.
- In the report: a separate chapter that describes what was found, without an estimated amount. This component is not included in the main amount.
What it is
An “unlawful dismissal” is a dismissal carried out in an improper way. For example, without a hearing, with a hearing held for appearances only, for a prohibited reason (such as pregnancy or reserve duty), or in bad faith.
There is no single law that defines it. The rules were developed in the case law of the National Labor Court. The basis for these rules: the duty of good faith in the Contracts Law, the equality laws, and laws that protect certain groups of employees.
A “hearing” (שימוע) is a conversation held before the decision. The employer tells you what it alleges, and you respond. The purpose is for the employer to truly hear you, and for you to have an opportunity to change the outcome — before the decision is made, not after it.
A hearing is required not only before a dismissal. It is also required before a material change in conditions: a transfer to another position, a reduction of the job scope, a wage cut or a change of workplace.
Who is entitled and when
Every salaried employee, at every workplace: private or public, large or small. There is no minimum seniority requirement.
What a proper hearing must include
- A written invitation, setting out the allegations: specific events and dates, not general allegations.
- Reasonable time to prepare. The law does not set how much time. It is assessed according to the circumstances.
- Access to the documents the employer relies on.
- The option to bring a representative or companion of your own, for example a workers’ committee representative or a family member.
- Genuine listening, with an open mind. If a replacement was already recruited before the hearing, or the dismissal notice was given right at its end, this may show that the decision was made in advance.
- A record of the conversation. It is customary to take minutes and give you a copy.
- A decision made after the hearing, that addresses what you said.
Not every flaw invalidates the hearing. If you knew what the allegations were, got a real opportunity to respond, and the employer considered what you said with an open mind, the hearing may be considered proper even if a certain detail was missing.
Dismissal for a prohibited reason
Some employees are specially protected by law, for example a pregnant employee or one on maternity leave, and an employee serving in reserve duty. For them there are rules of their own, and sometimes also compensation set by law: see maternity leave and reserve duty. The Equal Employment Opportunities Law (חוק שוויון ההזדמנויות בעבודה) also prohibits dismissal on discriminatory grounds, for example because of age, sex, religion or nationality.
How the amount is set, and what appears in the report
On what basis the labor court decides
According to the case law of the National Labor Court, for an unlawful dismissal a lump sum is awarded based on all the circumstances, and not as an automatic multiple of the wage.
The main considerations: how long you worked, the wage level, how serious the flaw was, your age and the difficulty of finding other work, and the harm to dignity. Since there is no dedicated law for this compensation, it also has no statutory ceiling. The special laws (for example on discrimination, pregnancy or reserve duty) have rules of their own.
What the report presents
- We read the documents: the dismissal letter, the invitation to the hearing, the minutes and the correspondence.
- We map what the hearing included and what was missing, against the list above, and check whether there is any sign of a prohibited reason.
- We describe the circumstances the labor court weighs: seniority, wage, the seriousness of the flaw, age and the difficulty of finding other work.
- We present the findings in the separate chapter, without an estimated amount, and not in the main amount.
There is no formula for compensation for dismissal without a hearing: the labor court awards a single sum based on all the circumstances, and the amounts actually awarded vary greatly from case to case. That is why the report does not estimate an amount for this component.
It is important to understand: the labor court may award compensation of any amount, or award none at all — for example when it is proven that even a proper hearing would not have changed the outcome.
A worked example
Suppose a regular monthly wage of ₪9,000 and 3 years of work. In the morning you received a WhatsApp message: “Come in at noon for a talk.” At the talk no allegation was specified, and at the end you were told you were dismissed. The next day a new employee was already working in your place.
There are several flaws here: there were no specific allegations, there was no time to prepare, and the decision appears to have been made in advance. In the report each flaw is described separately, together with the circumstances.
And in the same case there are also components that are calculated by law, and are included in the main amount:
- Notice period not given (monthly employee, after a year of work — one month)9,000 × 1₪9,000
- Severance pay (one month’s salary for each year of work)9,000 × 3₪27,000
- Before offsetting what was paid and what was contributed to severance in the fund₪36,000
The report describes the flaws in the hearing in the separate chapter, without an amount, and that chapter is not added to the main amount.
Common errors
- An invitation to a hearing on the same day, or by a short message without setting out the allegations.
- A “hearing” that is merely the delivery of a decision: the decision was already made, and a replacement already found.
- No minutes were provided, or the minutes do not reflect what was said.
- The employer sent you home until the dismissal took effect, and did not pay for those days. The hearing does not end the employment relationship. An employer who does not want you to come to work until then must pay you wages. That is already a wage component, which is included in the main amount.
What we check in the report
We read the dismissal letter, the invitation to the hearing, the minutes and the correspondence, and compare them with the list of the elements of a proper hearing. We also check whether there is any sign of a prohibited reason: pregnancy, reserve duty or discrimination.
The chapter “Components the labor court determines at its discretion” presents the findings — what the hearing included and what was missing — and the circumstances the labor court weighs, without an estimated amount. The components that arise from the dismissal itself, such as notice, severance pay and wages up to the last day, are checked separately and are included in the main amount.
Limitation period and deadlines
Most wage rights become time-barred after 7 years, and each month is counted separately. Some rights become time-barred sooner (for example, payment for unused leave), and contacting the employer alone does not stop the clock. Under our methodology, an unlawful dismissal claim is checked for 7 years from the day of dismissal.
And if you have not been dismissed yet, but only invited to a hearing? If the invitation is flawed, for example too short notice or no allegations specified, you can ask in writing to postpone the hearing and explain what is missing.
Frequently asked questions
I was in a trial period. Am I entitled to a hearing too?
Yes. The right to a hearing applies to all employees, regardless of seniority.
I was dismissed without a hearing. Can the employer fix that?
It depends on the circumstances. According to the case law of the National Labor Court, a meeting held after the employer has already decided to dismiss is usually not considered a genuine hearing.
Why is there no amount for this component in the report?
Because this amount cannot be calculated: the labor court sets it based on all the circumstances, and the amounts actually awarded vary greatly from case to case. So the report describes what was found, and the component is not included in the main amount.
Does this mean I will get the compensation?
No. The report shows what was found, and does not guarantee an outcome. The report is a numerical check of wages and rights under the law and the extension orders. It is not legal advice and does not replace it.
Sources
- Contracts Law (General Part), 1973 (חוק החוזים (חלק כללי), התשל״ג-1973) — section 39.
- Equal Employment Opportunities Law, 1988 (חוק שוויון ההזדמנויות בעבודה, התשמ״ח-1988) — section 2.
- Women’s Employment Law, 1954 (חוק עבודת נשים, התשי״ד-1954) — section 9.
- Discharged Soldiers (Reinstatement in Employment) Law, 1949 (חוק חיילים משוחררים (החזרה לעבודה), התש״ט-1949) — section 41A.
- Prior Notice of Dismissal and Resignation Law, 2001 (חוק הודעה מוקדמת לפיטורים ולהתפטרות, התשס״א-2001).
You were dismissed, and you’re not sure everything was done properly?
In the full check, wage auditors and payroll accountants go through every month and also check the dismissal procedure, together with all 28 rights. A clear report, one price: ₪999 incl. VAT. Still not sure? The quick check will show you in a minute whether there are signs worth checking.